Welcome to ChaosZone!
Prasenjeet Dutta's Home Page.

About this Post
Archives

Blog Mela 2005, Issue 3

Blog Mela - tour the Indian blogosphere Hello and welcome to the 3rd mela of the year! Without much ado –

The Philadelphia radio jockeys who dialed and harassed an Indian call centre worker got a lot of ink from many Indian bloggers this week. Shanti wondered why many Indians cried foul about racism when the jockeys should really have been excoriated for extremely poor judgement and taste. Psybaba posits that the complainers are too touchy by half and that Indians are not blameless when it comes to racial stereotyping.

On the other hand, even as radio jockeys are bad-mouthing call centre workers, JK notes that globalization affects more than IT and auto-parts — IT enabled services now include teaching.

Amit Varma’s posts on the tsunami were predictably nominated, but instead of pointing to the individual posts I’ll direct you to indiauncut-tsunami.blogspot.com where he’s helpfully compiled all his despatches from the tsunami affected areas of Tamil Nadu. Read it all.

Ravikiran, meanwhile, has been wondering why the government of India is intent on destroying the traditional livelihood of the thousands of fishermen who dot India’s long coastline with its new Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) measure. Yazadjal notes that the CRZ is a classic top-down bureaucratic response and offers an alternative.

Yazad also has a set of interesting posts (part 1, part 2) that touch upon the nature of capitalism as demonstrated by the rise in prices of staple goods has been a second disaster for the already-suffering tsunami victims. Pradeep has had similar thoughts and concludes that no-holds-barred capitalism cannot be the answer.

The tsunami could not break Madras/Chennai’s stride though — it was business as usual in the city. Vinod G notes the ATP Chennai Open finished a few days ago to good crowds, even if the highlight of the match for certain sections of the audience seemed to be a certain shirt-changing player.

India signed an agreement this week to build a oil and gas pipeline into the country from Burma through Bangladesh as well as, interestingly, Iran. Given that any Iranian pipeline has to travel through Pakistan (especially troublesome Balochistan), JK notes that this is an excellent opportunity for India to boost its image and build relations in a traditionally volatile part of the world.

The other issue that got a lot of ink was a little too meta, but considering it went right under the radar of most Indian English blogs, I felt it was worth covering. Madhu’s decision to exclude Hindi blogs in the last blog mela (based, as he notes, on very pragmatic reasons) sparked off a lively (and not always very friendly) discussion in the Hindi blog world, one of the first results of which was Chittha-charcha (blog review), a weblog devoted to a monthly roundup of Hindi blogdom, with other Indic languages to follow. I hope they do well, but as I’ve noted before, it’d be great if Indian bloggers used the distributed intelligence inherent in the blogosphere to minimize linguistic differences instead of exacerbating them.

On the other hand, in a post that surely is (fair) fuel for the language wars, Patrix asks why Indians pre-judge other Indians based on their command over English. Even though English receives equal standing with approximately 23 other languages, it is somehow more equal than others.

The petition currently before India’s Supreme Court to remove ‘Sindh’ from the national anthem was received with disbelief and derision from many bloggers. I just hope no one tells the plaintiff about the German anthem, which has Deutschland über alles stretching all the way from Holland to the Baltic.

Praveen submitted a well-written post about the bearded thief, which stood out by not really fitting in anywhere. But I’m guessing every Indian town and village has its characters, and thaadi kallan here could really be from anywhere in the country.

Food-blogging (or should that be food-and-beverages blogging?): Madhu Menon in his avatar as chef-incardinate at Shiok Food leads us to steamed rice nirvana, and even presents a lovely dish to go along with it — orange-lemon chicken, mmm… and Ravishankar Shrivastava has a paean to tea, the lubricant that keeps most Indians moving throughout the day. Then again, Inkspillz writes about life at college with a beverage of another kind.

Finally, food for the soul: Jitendra Chaudhary is out to create an easily accessible Ramayana in Devanagri on the web. So far, he’s got Part I — “baalkaand” — online. Blogger’s group-blogging capabilities could come in useful here, so go volunteer if stuff like this interests you.

That’s all for this week, folks. Thanks to all who nominated entries, and apologies to those whose entries I could not include. The next mela will be held on January 21 at selectiveamnesia.org. You can view the schedule (and volunteer) here.

Update 15 Jan 9:45pm: Updated post in response to this.

15 January 2005 3:22 am

21 Responses to “Blog Mela 2005, Issue 3”

  1. anup shukla Says:

    Congratulations for good coverage.

  2. Yazad Says:

    Absolutely fabulous! Amongst the best melas I’ve seen.

  3. A Says:

    Jus that it is 2005 now. Good Morning

  4. MadMan Says:

    Good work, Prasanjeet. I feel sorry for poor Nilesh.

  5. Prasenjeet Says:

    A: my blushes. Fixed.

  6. Jitendra Chaudhary Says:

    Thanks Prasenjeet,
    Thanks for including my Hindi Post.

  7. Ravikiran Says:

    Good work Prasenjit!
    Just a nitpick about the description of my entry about the CRZ. I don’t believe or even suspect that the government actually has designs on the traditional livelihood of fishermen. My point was that regardless of the intent, the net result was the same.

  8. amit varma Says:

    Outstanding blog mela, Prasenjeet, and I hope you realize that you’ve screwed us all by setting the bar so high! Well done.

  9. Prasenjeet Says:

    Ravi: I’ve updated the post. Sorry, that’ll teach me to procastinate and write up the mela at 2am.

    Glad many of you liked the mela, there was lots of great material to include.

  10. MadMan Says:

    Just to nitpick, “incardinate” is not a word. ;)

    (Glad you read my reasons for the Hindi posts in the my mela. How I wish people would stop saying that I don’t read Hindi. It’s now pissing me off royally.)

  11. Prasenjeet Says:

    :-) It’s as much of a word as “curiouser” is — see Twelfth Night, Act V, Sc 1, 167.

  12. Nitin Says:

    Prasenjeet,

    This is one of the better BBMs I’ve seen. Well done.

  13. P.X. Project Says:

    Thanks for including my post. :-)
    Appreciate it a lot.
    Cheers.

  14. Prashant Kothari Says:

    This may sound like a stuck record, but really great BBM — one of the posts that really struck a chord was Patrix’s re the arrogance of the English-walas..

    Unfortunately, the sad truth is that a person of average ability but with an impeccable public school accent and a strong English vocabulary always makes a better impression than than a person speaking an Indian language (any language) or for that matter, English with a strong accent. True of job interviews, of newscasters, or of corporate CEOs.

  15. Prasenjeet Says:

    Prashant: speaking the language of the streets won’t get one very far in Wall Street either. However, yes, the lack of respect Indian languages get (in business and media particularly) is directly related to the lack of power of the societies speaking those languages.

    If a Bengali or Gujarati or Tamil speaking society was affluent enough to pervasively use their language everywhere (including higher education) then things would have been different. As things stand, however, the only respect they get is when downmarket TV and cellphone vendors look to localize their wares.

    I’ve written about this before, w.r.t computer software — my belief is that because of the aspirational nature of the ‘climbers’ of the Indian middle class, Indian languages will have to content themselves with remaining second-rung in the commerical world, and diminish in influence as English primary education spreads.

  16. ramya Says:

    hey,
    am a fledgling at blogging. heard of blog mela last time it happened and figured it out by the time this one came up. thanks to Ravages.
    just dropped in to say great job!

    cheers!

  17. SV Says:

    First ever Gujarati blog

    For a long time I was keen on doing something for my language and that led me to start this Guajrati blog. Though it is very hard and tough to write. :(

    If you have time, do visit and share it with your friends.

    http://sv.typepad.com/guju/

  18. Paul Says:

    I agree with you

  19. Siddharth Shah Says:

    I have started Gujarati blog on internet. It is really fun.
    Please visit and let me know your views.

    http://drsiddharth.blogspot.com

    Siddharth Shah

  20. Jay Says:

    I have recently started a new blog (Gujarat News). I am planning to start posting… Please visit it if you get a chance.

    Gujarat News

  21. Kumar Says:

    Hello,

    I have write a blog on India Pakistan Relations.
    Please visit and let me know your views.

 

Copyright © 2001-2006, Prasenjeet Dutta. Terms of Use.

RSS Subscription Icon Subscribe

Powered by WordPress